Have you looked at Kuyaba? They have some small cottages from $56 a night. Sharon and I stayed at Kuyaba, in the Honey Moon suite, for two weeks in September. We really liked the the place and would stay there again. It is not far from the turn around and close to Burbon Beach- best jerk chicken in Negril. Their resturant is a bit expensive but there are lots of good places to eat near by for less.